A.O. asked for attorney fees twice before settling his domestic violence restraining order case. He obtained a one-year protective order. Fourteen months after the court filed it, he moved for fees and won $39,000. His former spouse appealed. On October 28, 2026, California’s First District Court of Appeal reversed the entire fee award. To understand why, start with what the spouses told the judge on the day they settled.
Both spouses had sought protection in San Mateo County. A.O. asked for a five-year restraining order in his trial brief. Alina Vologodskaya sought a three-year order. At the January 2024 hearing, they agreed to a one-year order protecting A.O., and Vologodskaya dismissed her own request with prejudice. The attorneys put the agreement on the record. Neither mentioned fees.
The parties knew how to leave an issue open. They expressly gave the judge authority to decide later how future bonuses or additional income would affect support. When A.O.’s attorney prepared the written orders, the findings after hearing marked attorney fees “not applicable.” The fee section of the restraining order was blank. The court filed both orders on February 1, 2024.
Why did the written record matter on appeal?
A.O. pointed to his earlier fee request and the form order’s general reservation of other issues. The justices read that language alongside the actual settlement. The parties had singled out future income, said nothing about returning for fees, and left no fee issue identified for later decision in either order. On this record, the general reservation did not preserve his fee claim.
The divorce itself remained open. The competing requests for protection, however, had been resolved. That distinction determined which order mattered. A.O. could not wait for a divorce judgment to start the clock on fees for the completed restraining order proceedings.
Could A.O. seek fees after the restraining order hearing?
Yes. The question was how long he had. A.O. relied on Faton v. Ahmedo, where the prevailing party sought fees on the very day the judge granted protection. That decision allowed a fee request after the hearing. It had no occasion to decide how late a party could file.
In A.O., the court held that California Rules of Court, rule 3.1702(b)(1), required service and filing of the Family Code section 6344 fee motion within the applicable time to appeal. By April 2025, when A.O. sought $75,476, even the ordinary 180-day outside period had passed. Vologodskaya raised timeliness before the trial judge, who nevertheless awarded $39,000.
Why didn’t the Court of Appeal send the case back?
A.O. asked the appellate court to let the trial judge consider whether good cause justified an extension. But he had never asked the trial judge for that relief, even after Vologodskaya objected and the court heard argument. He had forfeited the issue. The First District reversed the fee order and directed each side to bear its own appellate costs. On November 9, 2026, it denied A.O.’s petition for rehearing and his request to modify the opinion.
What should parties take from the decision?
At a settlement hearing, listen for what the judge is being asked to decide later. If fees remain disputed, identify whose fees, for which proceeding, and ask for a filing schedule. Check the written orders against the agreement before submitting them. If the other side objects that a motion is late, raise any grounds for an extension while the trial judge can still consider the evidence.
H. William “Bill” Edgar is the founding attorney of Edgar & Dow, a California family law firm with offices in Riverside and Murrieta. Admitted to the California State Bar in 1998 (Bar No. 197820), he represents clients in divorce, custody, support, property disputes, and family law appeals. He earned a B.A. in Political Science with a minor in History from the University of California, Santa Barbara, and a J.D. from Southwestern Law School. Read his full attorney profile at https://www.edgarfamilylaw.com/about-the-firm/our-team/h-william-edgar/.
Related Posts
The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.