A dispute over an approaching support deadline is often framed as all or nothing: either the recipient becomes fully self-supporting and payments end, or support continues unchanged. California law allows a more specific response. The evidence may justify additional time while also supporting a lower monthly payment.
In re Marriage of Berland addresses that middle ground. It is particularly important where employment efforts were inadequate but even reasonable diligence would not have eliminated the recipient’s need entirely. The court may distinguish the need that would remain from the additional dependence attributable to the failure to pursue work.
In re Marriage of Berland (1989) 215 Cal.App.3d 1257, 1260–1264 involved a support order anticipating progress toward employment. The wife sought continuation before the scheduled reduction to nominal support. The court extended substantial payments for sixteen months but reduced the monthly amount to $1,800. The appellate court affirmed.
The record supported a finding that she delayed pursuing realistic employment. After moving from a difficult fundraising search to real estate training, she progressed quickly. The court could consider what support she would have needed had reasonable diligence been exercised, rather than require the payer to finance the entire shortfall resulting from delay.
Separate the question of need from the question of effort
A recipient can have a genuine monthly deficit while also having failed to pursue reasonable opportunities. The existence of the deficit does not resolve how much the former spouse should be required to pay. Conversely, inadequate efforts do not necessarily establish that the recipient could have eliminated all need.
The evidence should address both questions. What could the person realistically have earned with reasonable efforts? What unmet need would remain? The answer should account for qualifications, employment opportunities, health, childcare, and the relevant circumstances rather than use an arbitrary salary assumption.
An extension involves both amount and duration
Berland recognizes discretion over the payment during an extension as well as how long the extension lasts. A court need not choose between preserving the entire original award and ending all assistance. It can tailor relief to the supported findings.
For a hypothetical spouse who could reasonably earn part-time income but still cannot meet appropriate needs, a lower support amount may be considered. If a supported training plan has a credible completion date, the duration and review provisions may address that transition. The proposed terms should explain why that particular combination is justified.
The prior order defines the expected conduct
Review what the recipient was told to do and when. The earlier judgment may describe employment expectations, require vocational assessment, or establish a conditional reduction. A later request should compare the recipient’s conduct with those expectations.
An order anticipating substantial employment efforts does not necessarily require pursuit of one specific occupation. But a person who repeatedly pursues a field with few suitable paid opportunities may need to explain why alternatives were not considered. The inquiry should remain practical rather than punish a preferred career choice merely because the payer dislikes it.
Assess the quality of an employment plan
A reasonable plan connects skills and training to available work. It considers the time and cost of obtaining qualifications, likely compensation, and the person’s ability to perform the job. A plan that repeatedly fails should be reassessed in light of actual results.
A vocational evaluator may help identify whether additional education is necessary or whether existing skills permit more immediate work. The evaluation should distinguish positions that are theoretically possible from those realistically available. Medical restrictions should be incorporated where supported.
The recipient should be prepared to explain material delays. Some delays may reflect genuine illness, caregiving demands, or circumstances outside the person’s control. Others may reflect decisions that did not reasonably advance self-support. The court needs evidence distinguishing those possibilities.
Do not skip changed circumstances or jurisdiction
A request to extend an existing order must still fit the judgment and the applicable modification requirements. The court’s discretion under Berland does not create jurisdiction after it has ended or override a valid restriction on modification.
In re Marriage of Khera & Sameer (2012) 206 Cal.App.4th 1467 addresses the need for a material change and a supported explanation of unrealized expectations. Our separate article discusses that threshold before the court determines appropriate relief.
Continued support is not a penalty or a reward
The objective is a support order justified by the evidence and applicable law. An employment dispute should not become an attempt to punish a former spouse through an unsupported reduction. Nor should an extension ignore meaningful evidence that avoidable choices increased dependence.
Family Code section 4320 requires consideration of the relevant circumstances, including earning capacity, need, ability to pay, health, duration, and hardships. A defensible proposal connects those circumstances to the requested monthly amount and time period.
Explain the proposed number
A request for a lower extension should identify the earnings attributed to the recipient and the basis for that figure. It should distinguish gross wages from spendable income and account for reasonable employment-related expenses. The payer’s financial condition must also be accurately presented.
For the recipient, opposing an arbitrary figure requires more than asserting that it is too low. The response should explain the realistic earning capacity, remaining expenses, and supported limits on employment. Both sides benefit from a record that allows the court to understand how the proposed amount was reached.
Discuss a partial extension
Edgar & Dow evaluates support extensions and reductions together with employment evidence and the existing judgment. Contact our office to discuss whether additional time, a different amount, or another support arrangement fits your circumstances.
Harold William Edgar is a family law attorney with Edgar & Dow in Riverside, California. He has practiced family law for more than 25 years, focusing on guiding clients through complex legal matters with skill and professionalism. Admitted to the California Bar in 1998, Mr. Edgar earned his J.D. from Southwestern University School of Law and his B.A. in Political Science and History from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is recognized by Avvo and Martindale-Hubbell for his strong legal knowledge and client service
The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.