A vocational evaluator may conclude that a spouse can earn a particular amount even though that spouse is not presently employed. That conclusion can affect spousal support. It does not automatically establish when the income should be attributed to the spouse or how quickly payments may be reduced.
In re Marriage of Schmir separates the evidence supporting employment from the notice and opportunity needed to obtain it. The case is useful for both sides: a supported spouse cannot always rely on continued unemployment, and a paying spouse cannot assume that an employability opinion justifies an immediate cutoff.
In re Marriage of Schmir (2005) 134 Cal.App.4th 43, 53–58 concerned a 61-year-old wife who had been unemployed for fourteen years. The appellate court found evidence supporting termination but held that the trial court acted too abruptly by failing to provide reasonable notice and an opportunity to obtain employment.
The evidence included vocational testimony, her activities, reduced medical expenses, and retirement resources. The decision did not find that long unemployment made income imputation impossible. Its central distinction was between a supported financial conclusion and the timing of the transition.
What does imputing income mean?
In this context, imputation means evaluating support using income the court finds a person could reasonably earn rather than only the wages currently received. The determination must be connected to the person’s actual earning capacity and the governing legal standards. An unsupported belief that “anyone can get a job” does not establish a particular salary.
The practical questions include the person’s qualifications, licensing, work history, health, suitable positions, and probable pay. Time matters too. A license may require renewal, an employer may require current training, and a search may take a reasonable period even for someone with marketable skills.
A warning communicates that reasonable efforts toward meeting support needs are expected and that failure may have financial consequences. It allows the recipient to act on that expectation. It should not be treated as a ceremonial paragraph that automatically establishes earnings or supplies a universal timetable.
The court must examine the actual history. A vocational proceeding, an agreement, or earlier orders may bear on awareness. Conversely, years of payments without a clear employment expectation may present a different situation. Schmir should not be converted into an absolute rule that income can never be imputed without a particular form of written warning.
Activities can be evidence, but context matters
Unpaid work and regular activities may help evaluate physical, emotional, or organizational capacity. They do not automatically prove the ability to perform a full-time paid job at a specified wage. The demands, frequency, accommodations, and flexibility of the activities need comparison with actual employment.
For a hypothetical caregiver who volunteers several hours a week, the evidence may show useful skills without showing the ability to sustain a five-day workweek. For another person performing demanding professional tasks without pay, the activity may support a different inference. The court needs facts supporting the comparison.
A vocational opinion should explain its assumptions
A useful evaluation identifies suitable work, the qualifications required, and the basis for its compensation estimate. If health restrictions are disputed, the relationship between those restrictions and proposed work must be addressed. If the evaluator assumes a current license or recent experience, those assumptions should be checked.
The opposing party may challenge the methodology, job availability, work schedule, or expected transition. The issue is not whether an expert used an impressive salary range. It is whether the opinion gives the court a reliable basis for the income attributed to this person.
Retirement resources involve a separate analysis
Schmir also considered retirement-account access and growth. Those parts of the opinion should be read alongside Dietz and the particular judgment. They do not establish an automatic rule that reaching an account-access age ends support.
In re Marriage of Dietz (2009) 176 Cal.App.4th 387 emphasizes the expectations expressed in a negotiated judgment. Our separate retirement-account article explains why the source of assets, settlement terms, and actual financial changes can affect the result.
Address timing in the requested order
A request involving imputed earnings should identify the proposed effective date and explain why that timing is supported. If a transition is needed, counsel should address its length and purpose. The same analysis applies when opposing a proposed immediate reduction: explain the practical steps needed and the evidence supporting the requested time.
A person who receives a warning should take it seriously. Keeping evidence of meaningful efforts is more useful than waiting for the next hearing and relying solely on the fact that no job has been found. The relevant record includes both efforts and barriers.
Review the evidence before seeking an immediate reduction
Edgar & Dow assesses earning-capacity disputes, employment expectations, and proposed transition terms. Contact our office to discuss an income-imputation request or an anticipated reduction in support.
Harold William Edgar is a family law attorney with Edgar & Dow in Riverside, California. He has practiced family law for more than 25 years, focusing on guiding clients through complex legal matters with skill and professionalism. Admitted to the California Bar in 1998, Mr. Edgar earned his J.D. from Southwestern University School of Law and his B.A. in Political Science and History from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is recognized by Avvo and Martindale-Hubbell for his strong legal knowledge and client service
The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.