Home
Blog
News
Pereira and Van Camp: Dividing Growth in a Separate Property Business

Pereira and Van Camp: Dividing Growth in a Separate Property Business

  |    |  
Last Modified on Nov 16, 2026

California Divorce Library · Edgar & Dow

A spouse may own a business before marriage or receive it by gift or inheritance. That separate ownership does not necessarily answer how growth produced during marriage should be allocated. When a spouse’s work contributes to a separate business, California law may recognize a community interest in the resulting increase or profits.

Pereira and Van Camp are approaches used to separate the return on separate property from the value attributable to community efforts. The appropriate method depends on the business and the evidence. Neither is a universal calculator.

First establish what was separately owned

Identify the interest at the beginning of the relevant period, its value, and any later acquisitions or ownership changes. Review shareholder or operating agreements, capitalization records, tax returns, financial statements, and transfers. A business formed before marriage may later acquire new assets or interests with funds of different character.

The analysis also requires a reliable ending value and an understanding of distributions and compensation during the period. Comparing two balance sheets without examining what was paid out can miss a substantial part of the economic result.

Business owner and adviser reviewing company financial records.

How does Pereira work?

Pereira generally allocates a reasonable return on the separate capital to the separate estate and treats the remaining growth attributable to the relevant period as community. It is often appropriate where the spouse’s personal efforts are a principal reason for the business’s success.

The reasonable rate of return must be supported by the circumstances. Although discussions of Pereira often mention a particular percentage used in a case, the law does not require the same rate for every business. Capital risk, industry conditions, and the evidence may justify a different approach.

As a simplified conceptual example, a business whose original separate capital was modest but whose success depended heavily on the owner’s sustained professional work may call for close attention to the community contribution. The calculation still must account for compensation and distributions already received without double counting them.

How does Van Camp work?

Van Camp generally focuses on the reasonable value of the spouse’s services to the business. The community receives the amount properly attributable to those services, with appropriate accounting for compensation and benefits already received, while the remaining return is allocated to the separate estate.

This approach may be appropriate where substantial capital, established systems, other employees, or market forces explain much of the business return. The fact that the owner worked hard does not prove that all appreciation resulted from that work. Conversely, a salary chosen by the owner does not establish that the community received fair compensation.

Why the court’s method matters

The court seeks an equitable allocation supported by the facts rather than mechanical adherence to a label. Different periods in a business’s development may justify different treatment. A start-up driven by one spouse’s efforts can evolve into an enterprise whose growth depends more heavily on accumulated capital and a management team.

Salary, distributions, retained earnings, and family expenses must be examined carefully. The rules governing deductions and prior community benefit are not identical under every method. An expert should explain each adjustment and how it avoids counting the same dollars twice.

What should a forensic accountant examine?

  • The business’s value and capital at the beginning and end of the relevant period.
  • The owner’s duties, working time, experience, and contribution to growth.
  • Market compensation for comparable services.
  • Compensation, distributions, personal benefits, and retained earnings.
  • Industry conditions, capital investment, and contributions by other workers.
  • Related-party transactions and changes in accounting practices.

The source records should support both the valuation and the allocation. An unexplained expert total is less useful than an analysis that identifies assumptions, alternative methods, and sensitivity to disputed facts.

Postseparation work raises another issue

Postseparation earnings from personal services are generally separate, but existing community capital does not disappear at separation. A community-owned business operated by one spouse after separation may require an allocation between separate labor and community capital. It is not enough to say that every later dollar belongs to the operator or that every later dollar remains community.

Prepare before discussing a buyout

Bring the ownership history, tax returns, financial statements, compensation records, and a description of the owner’s work. A useful settlement analysis identifies the accepted business value, the separate and community allocation, and how the buyout will be funded. It also distinguishes property division from any separate support analysis involving business income.

Related guides

Authorities and further reading

Rutter, California Practice Guide: Family Law (June 2026), chapter 8-B, paragraphs 8:335–8:354; Pereira v. Pereira (1909) 156 Cal. 1; Van Camp v. Van Camp (1921) 53 Cal.App. 17; Marriage of Brandes (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 1461.

Schedule a consultation with Edgar & Dow or call 951-684-6885. See our office and service-area information.

This article provides general information. Your documents, orders and case facts determine the available claims and procedures.

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

© Copyrights 2026 Edgar & Dow. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

*Images are obtained under license from Canva and other third-party stock image providers, with attribution included where required.

Digital Marketing by rizeup-logo