|
|
Last Modified on Nov 15, 2026
When I represent a parent in a custody evaluation, I prefer to draft the proposed scope myself. I identify the custody issues I want the evaluator to address and write specific questions for the evaluation. If the dispute is about three canceled exchanges, I want to know what happened at each exchange, why it fell through, and what would make future exchanges work for the child. Those questions shape the records we gather, the way we prepare for the interview, and what we look for when the report arrives.
A 730 custody evaluation is a court-ordered assessment by an expert appointed under Evidence Code section 730. The evaluator gathers information about the child and family to assist the judge with disputed custody or parenting-time issues. If you want to know why courts order evaluations or what an evaluator typically does, start with our California 730 custody evaluation overview.
I tell clients up front what an evaluation can add to the record and where it may leave questions open. The evaluator’s report can carry weight. We still need to be ready to explain what the report supports, where it goes beyond the evidence, and what order the judge should make.
Start with the scope of the evaluation
Read the signed Order Appointing Child Custody Evaluator (FL-327) and its attachments. Check whether it calls for a full or partial evaluation, which children and issues it covers, and whether the evaluator is asked to make recommendations about legal custody, parenting time, or a particular condition such as supervised exchanges. Note the fee allocation and any deadlines in the order. If a central issue is missing or the wording is unclear, raise it with your attorney early, before assuming the evaluator will address it.
California Rule of Court 5.220 requires the court to give the evaluator an order that specifies the purpose and scope before the evaluation begins. The evaluator also provides a written explanation of the process, including procedures, confidentiality limits, and costs. Compare those two documents. If the order addresses exchanges and the evaluator’s paperwork appears to assume a broader inquiry, ask your lawyer to clarify the difference before you respond. California Rule of Court 5.220.
In In re Marriage of Seagondollar (2006) 139 Cal.App.4th 1116, 1132–1133, the appointment order failed to define the purpose and scope. The evaluator went on to assess a proposed move to Virginia even though the move was outside the issues framed when he was appointed. The case shows why it matters to identify the actual dispute before the work starts.
How I would draft a gatekeeping inquiry
Gatekeeping describes conduct that affects a child’s access to the other parent. A canceled visit can involve interference, a genuine safety concern, or a problem arranging transportation or supervision. In In re Marriage of LaMusga (2004) 32 Cal.4th 1072, a move-away case, the California Supreme Court identified each parent’s willingness to support the child’s relationship with the other parent as one relevant factor. I ask about observable conduct and its effect on the child, including conduct by both parents. For the broader discussion, see our guide to restrictive gatekeeping and visitation refusal.
Suppose three supervised exchanges fell through. On the first date, the provider canceled. On the second, a protective order affected where or how the adults could meet. On the third, one parent canceled and the messages give no clear reason. A list of three missed visits captures the result. The appointment should give the evaluator enough direction to examine why the visits were missed and what each parent could have done within the applicable orders.
For that dispute, I might draft questions like these:
- What did the custody and any protective orders require on each date? Who had responsibility for arranging the supervisor, confirming the visit, and transporting the child?
- What do the provider’s records and the parents’ complete communications show about why each visit fell through? Where do the accounts differ?
- Did either parent propose a safe alternative or make-up visit consistent with the orders? How did the other parent respond?
- What effect did the missed contact and uncertainty have on the child? What changes to confirmation, transportation, or supervision would help the child have safe, predictable contact?
I would also specify whether the evaluator is being asked to recommend a change to the parenting schedule or to address how the existing schedule is carried out. If the evidence points to domestic violence, child abuse, or another safety concern, the inquiry should address it directly. California puts the child’s health, safety, and welfare first when those concerns conflict with the policy favoring frequent and continuing contact. In re Marriage of J.G..
What to bring to your first preparation meeting
Organize the packet around the questions in the scope. For the three exchanges, start with the operative custody order, any supervision or protective-order provisions, and a dated calendar. Put the provider’s cancellation notice beside the first date. Include the order in effect on the second date and the complete message thread for the third. Mark what you saw firsthand and what someone else reported. If you have an account of a missed visit with no independent record, identify where your information comes from.
A short index helps. Give each event a date, a sentence describing what happened, and a reference to the supporting record. Preserve original messages and include enough of the exchange to show context. If the other parent suggested a replacement visit or you missed a confirmation deadline yourself, include that too. It may explain the outcome and help you propose a procedure both parents can follow.
- Bring the appointment order, current custody order, and relevant attachments or protective orders.
- Prepare a dated chronology and a calendar showing both the ordered schedule and what actually took place.
- Identify people with firsthand knowledge, such as the supervisor who confirmed or canceled a visit. Note what each person observed.
- Write down the parenting terms you want, who would carry them out, and what should happen if a visit cannot go forward.
- Confirm with counsel how the evaluator accepts records and whom to copy. Review releases and sensitive school, medical, or therapy records before sending them.
The California Courts Child Custody Evaluation Information Sheet explains what parents can expect. Follow the appointment order and the evaluator’s written instructions about forms, interviews, releases, and submissions.
Choose records that answer the evaluator’s questions
A useful packet might include a school attendance record if missed visits affect Monday mornings, or a provider’s confirmation log if the parents disagree about who canceled. If the child’s reaction matters, identify who observed it and when. A teacher who saw the child arrive late can describe what happened at school. A supervisor who was at the exchange can describe who arrived and what was said. Give the evaluator a way to distinguish those observations from secondhand accounts.
If an important document is missing, note what it is and who may have it. For example, you may have a text saying the provider canceled without having the provider’s log. Tell your attorney what you have and ask how the log can be requested. That helps the evaluator see which parts of the chronology can be confirmed.
How to explain the issue in the interview
Tell the evaluator what the child’s week looks like and why the disputed terms matter. In the exchange example, you might explain that the child was ready for three visits that never happened, then walk through what you know about each cancellation. If the provider canceled, say so. If you could not comply with the planned location because of a protective order, identify the provision. If you do not know why the third visit was canceled, explain what the messages show and where your knowledge ends.
Be ready to explain the arrangement you would like going forward. A concrete proposal might assign one parent to confirm the provider by Thursday, require notice to both parents if the visit falls through, and provide a way to propose make-up time consistent with the orders. If a safety issue remains, explain what protection you believe is needed and why. Also be prepared to discuss what currently works for the child and what you can do to help exchanges go more smoothly.
Let the evaluator handle any interview with your child. Keep your explanations to your child age-appropriate and leave the merits of the case to the adults. Rule 5.220 governs aspects of how the evaluator gathers and communicates the child’s input. Family Code section 3042 governs how the court considers the child’s wishes and when the child can address the court. Evaluation rule and Family Code section 3042.
How to review the report against the original assignment
Read the report with the appointment order beside it. For each question in the scope, note where the evaluator answers it, which records or interviews support the answer, and what limits the evaluator identifies. Group your concerns into factual errors, missing information, and disagreements with a recommendation. For each material point, give counsel the page, the supporting record, and the change you are asking the judge to consider.
For example, if the report attributes all three canceled visits to one parent, flag the page and identify the provider’s cancellation notice and the protective order. Explain which dates each document addresses and why the distinction matters to the recommendation. If the report correctly describes the incidents but recommends an exchange location the supervisor cannot staff, identify the availability problem and propose a workable alternative. That gives your attorney a concrete issue to raise at the hearing.
If the court directs a written report under Family Code section 3111, the evaluator must file it confidentially and serve it on the parties or their attorneys and any appointed counsel for the child at least 10 days before the custody hearing. Review the confidentiality notice before sharing the report or discussing its contents with anyone outside the case. The judge decides what custody order to make. Family Code section 3111.
What if the report leaves a question unanswered?
Check whether the evaluator explains why. A record may have been unavailable, an interview may have been limited, or the appointment may not have covered the issue. Rule 5.220 requires the evaluator to describe limitations and present relevant information, including information that does not support the conclusions. For the exchange example, identify whether the supervisor’s account was considered and how its absence affects the recommendation. California Rule of Court 5.220(f).
Discuss timing with your attorney as soon as you receive the report. If the hearing is close, lead with the points that could affect the order. In the exchange example, that might be whether a provider is available on the recommended day or whether the exchange location complies with an existing protective order. Bring the record that supports the concern and a specific alternative the judge can consider.
Frequently asked questions
Who pays for a 730 custody evaluation?
Check the appointment order for who pays, in what amounts, and when. Peterson v. Thompson (2023) 89 Cal.App.5th 988 requires the court to consider ability to pay when allocating court-appointed custody evaluation fees. If the allocation is disputed, bring information about income, necessary living expenses, and other financial obligations.
How long will the evaluation take?
The timeline depends on the scope, the availability of people and records, and the court’s schedule. Read the appointment order and confirm interview dates, expected report timing, and any payment or intake deadlines. Raise a scheduling or accessibility concern promptly with counsel so it can be addressed through the appropriate process.
Prepare for your 730 evaluation with Edgar & Dow
If a custody evaluation is being discussed or has already been ordered, bring the proposed scope or signed appointment order, the current custody orders, and your next hearing date. Schedule a consultation with Edgar & Dow to discuss the questions the evaluation should address and how to prepare for the interview.
Explore the California Child Custody and Visitation Library for more guides on evaluations and hearings.
Related