Start Intake Online

Home
Blog
Family Law
Recordings at Supervised Custody Exchanges: Malinowski v. Martin

Recordings at Supervised Custody Exchanges: Malinowski v. Martin

  |    |  
Last Modified on Nov 16, 2026

By H. William Edgar | Edgar & Dow
Reviewed November 2026. Part of the Domestic violence / DVRO library.

Malinowski v. Martin (2024) 104 Cal.App.5th 559 addresses recordings of court-ordered supervised custody exchanges. It should not be read as blanket permission to record every supervised visit, telephone call, or conversation involving a child.

What happened in the case?

Malinowski sought to add the children as protected parties under an existing DVRO. Dashcam recordings captured supervised exchanges in a public parking lot. The trial court excluded the recordings under Penal Code section 632 on the ground that they captured confidential communications.

In the published portion of the opinion, the Court of Appeal found that the communications at issue were not confidential. The exchanges were subject to court-ordered monitoring and documentation, and their public setting allowed others to overhear. The ruling concerned those circumstances, not all parent-child contact.

What makes a communication confidential?

Section 632 uses an objective test tied to the circumstances and a reasonable expectation of confidentiality. Whether a person reasonably expects that others may overhear or record the communication matters. The fact that another adult is present does not supply a universal answer for every setting.

A private phone conversation, a visit in a home, and an exchange monitored under a court order can present materially different facts. Other privacy laws and specific court orders also may apply.

Does a DVRO itself permit recording?

Do not assume so. Statutory exceptions concerning recording for protective purposes have conditions. In Malinowski, the court did not accept a general theory that the existing order authorized recording the parent’s communications with the children. The scope of the order and the requirements of the claimed exception mattered.

Lawful recording and admissibility are separate questions

Even a lawfully obtained recording may require authentication and a showing of relevance. Completeness, hearsay, and other evidentiary objections can remain. Preserve the original file, associated date information, and the surrounding context. An edited clip can create disputes about what has been omitted.

Before the hearing, identify who can explain how the recording was made and whether the court has procedures for submitting or playing electronic exhibits. Do not assume that having a video on a phone means it can be played without preparation.

What should counsel review before recording?

  • The exact custody, supervision, and protective orders.
  • Whether the proposed recording captures audio, video, or both.
  • The location, participants, and reasonable privacy expectations.
  • The specific statutory exception, if one is claimed.
  • How existing recordings were obtained, preserved, and disclosed.

Discuss the circumstances before creating additional recordings. A useful piece of evidence should not come at the cost of violating a privacy statute or a court order.

Sources and related resources

Malinowski v. Martin; Penal Code section 632.

Explore the domestic violence / dvro library or schedule a consultation with Edgar & Dow. We review the facts, explain the available options, and identify the legal work required. General information only; the governing law, facts, and existing orders determine the result.

Discuss your case with Edgar & Dow

Tell us your county, the issue you need help with, and any upcoming hearing or deadline.

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

© Copyrights 2026 Edgar & Dow. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

*Images are obtained under license from Canva and other third-party stock image providers, with attribution included where required.

Digital Marketing by rizeup-logo