Children Held Hostage: Identifying Brainwashed Children, Presenting a Case, and Crafting Solutions
Stanley S. Clawar and Brynne V. Rivlin. Second edition, ABA Book Publishing, 2013.
“My ex is turning the children against me” describes a serious concern. It does not yet tell a judge what happened. A stronger presentation identifies the conduct, the reliable evidence, the effect being claimed, and the order sought.
Children Held Hostage belongs in the custody hub because it connects allegations of parental influence with the practical questions of identification and proof. At Edgar & Dow, that connection is central: taking interference seriously means doing the work to establish it.
The ABA’s description presents the second edition as a practice-focused treatment of identifying an alienated child, presenting a case, and developing possible responses. It describes an expanded body of observations involving more than 1,000 families, along with material about parental influence, gender, and questions faced by judges and practitioners. The authors use terms including programming and brainwashing. [1]
Those are the authors’ terms, not findings that follow simply because a family resembles an example. The publisher’s account of the number of families does not establish a population prevalence rate or validate every proposed inference. Our discussion below concerns evidence preparation; its examples are original illustrations, not cases extracted from the book.
First, what did an adult actually do? Second, what is occurring in the child’s relationship with a parent? Third, what supports a connection between the two? These questions are related, but they require different evidence.
A message refusing an ordered exchange may establish what the adult said. It does not, without more, establish why the child later expressed anger. Likewise, a child repeating an adult phrase may prompt inquiry about its source, but it does not automatically establish coaching.
Be equally careful when the evidence favors your own position. A photograph of one happy afternoon does not disprove a child’s report about a different incident. A serious presentation accounts for the whole relevant history.
Assume both parents are permitted to attend a school event. One parent requests the date several times and receives no response. Afterward, a message states, “I told her you did not care enough to come.” The child then accuses the absent parent of not caring.
The useful evidence includes the actual event notice, the information requests, the reply, and any independently available school information. It also includes facts that might weaken the claim: perhaps the other parent had already received the notice directly or had said they could not attend.
A clear presentation explains the information gap and the later statement. It does not need to begin with a sweeping claim about the other parent’s personality. If the child’s account came to you through a third party, identify that source instead of presenting the statement as something you personally heard.
| Record | What to include |
|---|---|
| Scheduled contact | The date, the relevant order provision, and what actually occurred. |
| Explanation | The reason given at the time, with the complete communication. |
| Corroboration | Lawfully obtained records or witnesses that support or challenge the account. |
| Child’s experience | What was observed, what was reported, and who supplied the information. |
| Proposed response | A specific change linked to the problem shown by the evidence. |
Include relevant events that went well. If six exchanges occurred without difficulty and two did not, say so. If an emergency explained one cancellation, preserve that explanation. A chronology should help counsel evaluate the dispute, not conceal the parts that complicate the accusation.
Keep complete message threads and original files where available. Label copies with dates and a short description. Do not edit a screenshot so that the surrounding exchange changes meaning. Avoid making the child responsible for gathering documents or obtaining admissions from the other household.
Do not secretly record conversations or access another person’s accounts on the assumption that useful evidence makes the method lawful. Ask counsel about the particular records and how to obtain them. Legal access, evidentiary foundation, and privacy are separate questions from whether information appears relevant.
When a child volunteers something concerning, listen without turning the conversation into an interview designed for court. Repeated questioning can burden the child and complicate the reliability of the account. A lawyer or qualified professional can help determine the appropriate next step.
A missed exchange and the cause of a child’s rejection are not the same evidentiary problem. The first may turn largely on the order and communications. The second may require specialized assessment of the family, the child’s experiences, competing explanations, and the suitability of a proposed intervention.
California Rule of Court 5.220 requires court-ordered custody evaluators to maintain objectivity, gather balanced information, address limitations, and include relevant information that does not support their conclusions. [2] Those duties matter when an evaluator is asked to move from behavior to an opinion about cause.
A proposed evaluation should identify the questions to be answered. Asking an expert to “prove alienation” starts with a conclusion. Asking what explains the contact problem and what arrangements would address it leaves room for an evidence-based answer.
If the evidence concerns repeated uncertainty about exchanges, the proposed solution should address exchanges. If the dispute concerns withheld information, explain the information needed and a workable method for sharing it. If the child reports harmful parenting, that concern needs its own examination.
Some families need more extensive assessment or changes. The seriousness of a claim does not remove the need to explain why the particular response serves the child. A court filing should make that connection understandable.
This is a useful professional companion to the more parent-focused books in the series. Its subject encourages a necessary shift from general accusations to identification, proof, and practical responses. We would read its terminology critically and test its proposed inferences against the facts, current law, and alternative explanations in the particular case.
Not necessarily. Orders and communications may resolve a discrete factual dispute. Expert involvement becomes more important when the disputed issues involve psychological causation, the child’s presentation, or a proposed treatment.
No. Publication identifies the source of the book. The authors’ analysis must still be assessed, and the court applies governing law and evidentiary requirements.
Preserve the complete records, then provide an organized chronology and representative examples. Ask counsel how the remaining material should be delivered and reviewed.
Source note: This book-informed discussion draws on the author or publisher materials and bibliographic sources listed below; it is not a review of the complete text. Everyday scenarios and suggested language are original illustrations. They are not quotations, verified book anecdotes, or a diagnostic checklist.
For the broader framework, read our guide to parental alienation, restrictive gatekeeping, and the resist–refuse dynamic in California custody cases.
General educational information; application depends on the facts and current law.
© Copyrights 2026 Edgar & Dow. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
*Images are obtained under license from Canva and other third-party stock image providers, with attribution included where required.
Digital Marketing by