By H. William Edgar | Edgar & Dow
Part of the California Parentage & Paternity Library.
After assisted reproduction, California parentage can depend on consent and intent rather than genetic connection alone. Family Code section 7613 distinguishes an intended parent from a donor. The method of conception, the agreements made before conception, and later parenting conduct can all matter.
“We used a donor” is not a complete legal description. Identify who supplied the sperm, eggs, or embryo; who intended to parent; who conceived; and what each person agreed to before the pregnancy.

Family Code section 7613 recognizes an intended parent who consents to the specified assisted reproduction using donated genetic material. The intended parent and the person conceiving should sign the required written consent. If that writing is missing, the statute permits a finding based on clear and convincing evidence of the required preconception oral agreement.
That alternative is an evidentiary rule, not a sound reason to skip written planning. Fertility-clinic paperwork, messages, and testimony may become disputed years later. An agreement should address the actual arrangement and all people whose interests are involved.
Under section 7613(b), a nonspouse donor who provides semen to a licensed physician and surgeon or sperm bank for assisted reproduction ordinarily is not a parent based on that donation. A written preconception agreement that the donor will be a parent changes the analysis.
When conception occurs outside that route, such as home insemination, the statute looks for a signed preconception nonparentage agreement or clear and convincing proof of the specified oral agreement. Sexual intercourse is not assisted reproduction for this purpose. A donor label or a later promise cannot be assumed to satisfy the statute.
Sections 7613(c) and (d) address egg and embryo providers separately. The provider’s relationship to the recipient and the parties’ intent matter. Where genetic material passes through someone other than its original source, the original providers’ written consent or another statutory basis also must be considered.
Family Code section 7613.5 supplies optional statutory agreement forms for several arrangements. One form establishing two intended parents’ consent does not necessarily dispose of a separate donor’s rights. Each relationship must be addressed.
Potentially. Jason P. v. Danielle S. (2017) 9 Cal.App.5th 1000 distinguishes a claim based only on sperm donation from a claim based on an actual parental relationship satisfying section 7611(d). A donor cannot demand an opportunity to create that relationship merely because of genetics.
A completed adoption or termination of parental rights introduces a different obstacle. C.C. v. L.B. (2024) 106 Cal.App.5th 1323 rejected an attempt to claim presumed and third-parent status after the donor had consented to adoption and termination of his rights. Continued contact did not undo that legal event.
Section 7613(e) permits a qualifying written agreement renouncing legal interests in embryos with the specific intent not to be a parent of a child conceived through their use. All persons with the required legal interests or control must sign. For married parties, the statute requires incorporation into a final dissolution decree before the agreement becomes legally binding.
An embryo-disposition dispute is not resolved simply by applying custody law to an existing child. The agreement, consent records, and statutory requirements need review. Pham v. Superior Court (2025) 117 Cal.App.5th 115 illustrates the importance of the actual IVF contract language.
Usually DNA cannot answer whether someone consented to be an intended parent. Section 7551 restricts testing used to challenge protected assisted-reproduction parentage or establish a statutory donor’s parentage. Read who can request genetic testing before treating a test as the next step.
A gestational carrier arrangement has additional requirements. Our surrogacy and pre-birth orders guide explains the separate framework.
Misuse of sperm, eggs, or embryos can raise claims separate from deciding the child’s legal parents. Civil Code section 1708.5.6 provides a damages claim for misuse that violates Penal Code section 367g. That criminal statute addresses specified knowing uses or implantation without the required written consent, subject to its exceptions.
Preserve consent forms, clinic records, and communications. A claim for damages does not itself establish or erase parentage. The parentage proceeding, potential civil claim, and any criminal investigation have different requirements and deadlines.
Principal authorities: Family Code sections 7551, 7606, 7611, section 7613, section 7613.5, and 7630(f); Jason P. v. Danielle S. (2017); C.C. v. L.B. (2024); Pham; and Rutter, California Practice Guide: Family Law (2026), paragraphs 6:16–6:16.10. These include the embryo-related changes enacted through AB 1650, effective January 1, 2024.
Edgar & Dow represents clients in California parentage, custody, and support matters. Contact our office to discuss representation. This article provides general legal information; the available procedure depends on the facts, existing orders, and law governing the claim.
© Copyrights 2026 Edgar & Dow. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
*Images are obtained under license from Canva and other third-party stock image providers, with attribution included where required.
Digital Marketing by