Home
Blog
Custody
Parenting Tests, Behavior Checklists, and Projective Techniques in Custody Evaluations

Parenting Tests, Behavior Checklists, and Projective Techniques in Custody Evaluations

  |    |  
Last Modified on Nov 15, 2026

By H. William Edgar | Edgar & Dow

A psychological evaluation may include several instruments with impressive names. The number of tests does not tell the court whether the evaluation answered the right question. Each instrument needs a purpose, a suitable method of administration, and a defensible connection to the opinion offered.

Parenting inventories, behavior checklists, symptom questionnaires, and projective techniques address different kinds of information. They should not be treated as interchangeable measures of who should receive custody. Understanding the distinctions helps parents read a report and helps lawyers prepare focused questions.

Ask what each instrument was intended to measure

A parenting stress measure asks a different question from an intelligence test. A depression questionnaire addresses a different subject from a teacher’s description of classroom behavior. An assessment of the relationship between two parents does not necessarily establish either parent’s conduct during a particular incident.

Before debating a score, identify the instrument, edition, respondent, date, and stated purpose. Then identify the conclusion the evaluator drew from it. The crucial issue is whether the method supports that conclusion in this setting.

Older professional references discuss instruments such as the ASPECT, Bricklin measures, sentence completion tasks, and various relationship inventories. Their inclusion in a reference book is a reason to investigate their use, not proof that every instrument is suitable for every current custody evaluation. Counsel should ask for the research and interpretive materials supporting the particular application.

Parenting stress is a subject for assessment, not a custody verdict

The publisher describes the Parenting Stress Index, Fourth Edition as assessing stress within the parent-child system, including parent, child, and situational factors. That purpose is more specific than deciding which parent should prevail in litigation.

If a report relies on a stress score, ask what the score adds to the evaluation. What stressors were identified? What additional information supports the interpretation? Were the child’s needs, available assistance, and the circumstances of the assessment considered? What recommendation follows from the concern, and why?

A parent managing substantial demands may need practical support. A high level of reported stress does not explain, by itself, whether the parent meets the child’s needs. Conversely, a reassuring score cannot erase documented failures of supervision. The evaluator should connect the information rather than allowing either the score or the anecdote to carry the entire conclusion.

Identify who supplied the information on a behavior checklist

A report may contain ratings completed by a parent, teacher, child, or another caregiver. Names such as the Behavior Assessment System for Children and the Achenbach System of Empirically Based Assessment should prompt a basic inquiry: which form was used, who completed it, and what period and setting did the respondent describe?

Consider a disagreement between a parent’s account and a teacher’s account. The disagreement deserves examination. It does not establish, without further analysis, that either person is lying. The observations may concern different situations, times, or expectations. Counsel can identify what each respondent actually observed and ask how the evaluator addressed the difference.

The report should make attribution clear. “The parent reported difficulty sleeping” is not the same as “the examiner observed difficulty sleeping.” When several sources repeat information originally supplied by one person, the repetition should not be mistaken for several independent observations.

Symptom questionnaires require a defined role

A depression or anxiety questionnaire may contribute information about reported symptoms. The evaluator should explain whether it was used for screening, monitoring, or another purpose, and what further assessment supported any diagnosis or opinion.

The legal question usually requires additional steps. Which symptoms, if established, affect a specific parenting task? What is known about frequency, severity, duration, and current functioning? What records or observations support those conclusions? A questionnaire score should not silently become a finding that a parent cannot safely care for a child.

The date also matters. A measure administered during one period should be described as information from that period. If the evaluator uses it to describe a later condition, the report should explain the basis for doing so.

Projective techniques need a clearly explained foundation

Reports may refer to the Rorschach, Thematic Apperception Test, Children’s Apperception Test, drawings, or sentence completion tasks. The proper response is neither automatic acceptance nor automatic rejection based solely on the name. Ask what procedure and scoring approach were used, what proposition is being supported, and what evidence supports that use.

A drawing can be part of an interaction without every detail having a proven psychological meaning. If an examiner attributes significance to a particular feature, the examiner should explain the basis, the alternatives considered, and the limits of the inference. A conclusion about abuse, credibility, or parenting capacity requires more than an unexplained interpretation of an image or story.

This distinction is especially important when a report uses a technique to move from a general concern to a specific historical allegation. Counsel should identify that step explicitly and examine whether the professional has a reliable basis for making it.

Evaluate the combination of methods

Several weakly connected observations do not become independent corroboration simply because they appear in different sections of a report. Counsel should trace the source of each significant fact and identify whether different methods actually provide distinct information.

The governing questions in a California court-connected custody evaluation include the adequacy of the information and the reasoning supporting the recommendations. California Rule of Court 5.220 provides the framework for that process. A professional should explain limitations and meaningful contrary information rather than presenting only material that favors the final conclusion.

Use testing questions to prepare a useful examination

At Edgar & Dow, the examination starts with the recommendation that matters to the case. We identify the information said to support it, distinguish observation from self-report, and assess whether the expert’s reasoning reaches the parenting issue before the court. Testing becomes one part of the evidence alongside records, witnesses, and actual caregiving history.

Parents can assist by identifying factual errors and supplying relevant records through the proper process. They should not try to manipulate answers or obtain protected test materials. The goal is an accurate assessment and a fair opportunity to examine its use.

Professional reference and related reading

Professional reference used by the firm: Marc J. Ackerman and Andrew W. Kane, Psychological Experts in Divorce Actions, 5th ed. (Wolters Kluwer Law & Business, 2011). This is a historical practice reference. The legal authorities and current professional resources linked in this article support the present discussion.

Explore the California Child Custody and Visitation Library for related guidance on parenting time, evidence, evaluations, and contested hearings.

For help preparing your custody case, schedule a consultation with Edgar & Dow.

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

© Copyrights 2026 Edgar & Dow. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

*Images are obtained under license from Canva and other third-party stock image providers, with attribution included where required.

Digital Marketing by rizeup-logo