A mental health professional’s title tells you something about training and licensure. It does not tell you everything about the person’s role in your custody case. Your therapist, your child’s therapist, a court-appointed evaluator, and an expert retained to review a report may have very different assignments.
Before deciding what an opinion means, ask three questions: Who is this person? What were they asked to do? What information did they actually obtain? Those questions help explain both the value and the limits of the professional’s involvement.
These are starting points. A professional’s usefulness depends on the actual problem. A dispute about medication may require different expertise from a question about an assessment instrument, a child’s developmental needs, or the method used to investigate family interactions.
A custody evaluator has a court-related assignment
A custody evaluator investigates specified issues to assist the court. The evaluator’s task comes from the appointment and applicable law. It is different from providing treatment to help one person manage symptoms or cope with the separation.
California Rule of Court 5.225 addresses qualifications for court-appointed custody evaluators. It recognizes several licensing categories, including psychologists, qualifying psychiatrists, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, and certain professional clinical counselors. It also contains specified exceptions. Licensure alone does not resolve the additional training and experience requirements.
“Custody evaluator” therefore describes a role, not a single academic degree. “Doctor” is not a substitute for examining the relevant qualifications. Nor does a professional’s appearance on a list establish that the person is the right fit for every disputed issue.
A treating therapist and an evaluator answer different questions
A treating therapist may help a parent address anxiety, grief, anger, or a difficult relationship. A child’s therapist may focus on the child’s symptoms and treatment needs. Their information is gathered in the context of those services.
A custody evaluator has a different assignment: investigating the court’s questions using an appropriate evaluation process. A therapist who has treated one parent may never have interviewed the other parent, observed either parent with the child, or reviewed the records relevant to the disputed parenting schedule.
That does not make treatment information worthless. It means the proposed testimony must be considered in light of the witness’s actual work. Observations of a patient’s progress, an account of what the patient reported, and an opinion about which parent should receive custody are different propositions.
For example, a counselor may have directly observed a child’s distress during appointments. That observation does not, by itself, establish the cause of the distress. The professional may have useful information while still lacking a basis to resolve every disputed allegation.
Can my therapist testify for me?
Possibly, but the answer requires attention to the proposed subject, privilege, confidentiality, the witness’s knowledge, and the applicable procedure. Do not ask a therapist for a custody recommendation without first discussing the purpose and consequences with your attorney.
Start by identifying what needs to be proved. Is the issue attendance at appointments, observations during treatment, the existence of a diagnosis, compliance with a treatment recommendation, or a broader opinion about parenting? Different information and legal questions arise for each.
Involving a treating professional in litigation can also affect the treatment relationship. Counsel should consider whether the information can appropriately be presented, what records may be implicated, and whether another qualified expert is needed for a distinct forensic question. A decision to obtain treatment is not automatically consent to unrestricted disclosure of everything discussed.
A retained expert may have a narrower role
A party may retain an expert to consult about a particular issue, review another expert’s work, or offer admissible testimony. Evidence Code section 733 preserves the ability to produce other expert evidence concerning a matter addressed by a court-appointed expert. It does not guarantee admission of every proposed opinion or require a second full evaluation.
A reviewing psychologist might examine whether a report’s conclusions follow from its stated data. That assignment is different from interviewing the family and making an independent parenting recommendation. The review must be described accurately so the court understands what the witness did and did not assess.
Before incurring fees, identify the question a second expert would answer. A targeted review may be useful when a recommendation depends heavily on a disputed test interpretation. It may add little when the central problem is a school calendar or an incorrectly recorded work schedule.
What makes someone qualified to give the particular opinion?
Evidence Code section 720 connects expert qualification to the subject of the testimony. The question is whether the witness has sufficient relevant knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education.
Ask about the issue rather than collecting impressive titles. What experience does the proposed expert have with the child’s developmental needs? With the type of testing used? With evaluating alleged abuse? With the difference between treatment information and forensic conclusions?
Consider an expert asked to address a child’s resistance to contact. The useful inquiry is how that person investigates possible explanations, including the child’s experiences with each parent, safety concerns, relationship difficulties, and possible influence by another person. A general statement that the expert handles “high-conflict cases” does not describe that method.
Diagnosis, parenting capacity, and a custody recommendation are different
Learning the name of a diagnosis may help identify questions for a qualified professional. It does not complete the custody analysis. Counsel needs to understand the asserted connection between symptoms and the parent’s actual responsibilities: supervision, judgment, emotional availability, transportation, or response to the child’s needs.
The same is true when there is no diagnosis. A parent can engage in harmful conduct that needs proof and a legal response without the dispute becoming a diagnostic exercise.
Describe the behavior and its effect before assigning a label. If an opinion relies on a condition, ask how it was evaluated, whether the expert is qualified to address it, and what information supports the proposed parenting restrictions or recommendations.
Questions to ask before the professional becomes involved
Who is retaining or appointing the professional, and who pays?
Is the assignment treatment, evaluation, consultation, or testimony?
What question is the person expected to answer?
Who will be interviewed and what records may be reviewed?
Who can receive the resulting information or report?
What limits on confidentiality apply?
What happens if the professional identifies a question outside their expertise?
Ask these questions early. They help avoid an expensive mismatch between the service purchased and the evidence the case actually requires.
How Edgar & Dow fits expert work into trial preparation
A family-law trial may involve parents, teachers, treating professionals, financial experts, evaluators, and other witnesses. Each must be connected to a fact or opinion that matters. Trial preparation includes deciding what testimony is needed, laying the appropriate foundation, addressing objections, and preparing direct examination and cross-examination.
At Edgar & Dow, we examine a psychological expert’s role within that larger evidentiary plan. We consider the person’s qualifications, information, methods, and limits before deciding how an opinion should be presented or tested. Ackerman and Kane’s Psychological Experts in Divorce Actions is one professional reference in the firm’s library; current law and appropriate current professional materials guide the specific legal analysis.
Contact Edgar & Dow if a therapist, evaluator, or proposed expert is becoming part of your case. Bring the appointment or engagement documents and identify the question the professional is being asked to answer.
Common questions
Is a psychiatrist always a better custody expert?
No professional title answers that question by itself. Compare the person’s relevant expertise with the disputed issues, the proposed assignment, and the applicable qualifications.
Can an LCSW conduct a custody evaluation?
Clinical social workers are among the licenses recognized by rule 5.225. The applicable training, experience, and other requirements still need to be satisfied.
Does hiring an expert mean the judge must accept the opinion?
No. Qualification, admissibility, the factual basis, and the opinion’s persuasive value remain separate questions. The judge decides the custody issues.
Professional reference and related reading
Professional reference used by the firm: Marc J. Ackerman and Andrew W. Kane, Psychological Experts in Divorce Actions, 5th ed. (Wolters Kluwer Law & Business, 2011). This is a historical practice reference. The legal authorities and current professional resources linked in this article support the present discussion.
Harold William Edgar is a family law attorney with Edgar & Dow in Riverside, California. He has practiced family law for more than 25 years, focusing on guiding clients through complex legal matters with skill and professionalism. Admitted to the California Bar in 1998, Mr. Edgar earned his J.D. from Southwestern University School of Law and his B.A. in Political Science and History from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is recognized by Avvo and Martindale-Hubbell for his strong legal knowledge and client service
The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.