|
|
Last Modified on Nov 15, 2026
By H. William Edgar | Edgar & Dow
A psychological evaluation in a custody case should help answer a defined question about the child and family. Understanding that question is the first step toward understanding the interviews, records, observations, and any testing that follow.
Parents sometimes imagine that an evaluator administers a test and the score determines who receives custody. The actual task is more complicated. Information must be gathered, interpreted, and connected to the issue the court needs to decide. The judge remains responsible for the custody order.
This article focuses on how an evaluation reaches its conclusions. Our 730 evaluation overview explains the appointment process, and our preparation guide explains how to organize your participation.
Begin with the question the court needs answered
An evaluation might concern a broad parenting plan or a narrower issue. A proposed overnight schedule, an allegation of impaired supervision, a child’s refusal to visit, and a dispute about educational needs do not necessarily call for the same investigation.
Read the appointment order for its purpose and scope. Identify the questions, deadlines, anticipated report, and fee arrangements. If a central question is missing or unclear, raise that concern through counsel before assuming the evaluator will address it.
Suppose the dispute concerns a child arriving late to school after overnight visits. Useful questions include when the late arrivals occurred, what caused them, whether the pattern continues, and what arrangement would solve it. A generalized request to determine which parent is “more responsible” may obscure those practical issues.
Understand the process before supplying information
California Rule of Court 5.220 requires a written explanation of the evaluation process, including its purpose, procedures, report distribution, confidentiality limits, and costs. Where psychological tests will be used, their role in assessing other information or conclusions must be explained.
Ask how records should be submitted, whether there are limits, how collateral contacts are identified, and what authorizations are requested. An organized submission is easier to assess than a series of unrelated emails sent whenever a new argument occurs.
Tell counsel and the evaluator about relevant language needs, accommodations, safety concerns, and existing protective orders. Those issues should be addressed in the arrangements for participation rather than left to surface unexpectedly during an interview.
Interviews provide information that still needs evaluation
An interview gives a parent an opportunity to describe the child’s needs, caregiving history, family relationships, and disputed events. It is also an opportunity for the evaluator to ask follow-up questions and examine explanations.
Separate observations from conclusions. “My daughter cried before the exchange” describes an observation. “She cried because the other parent is dangerous” adds a causal explanation that requires examination. A useful investigation considers the circumstances and available supporting information.
Give concrete examples. Explain what occurred, when, who was present, and what records or witnesses may help. Acknowledge when you do not know. Trying to fill every gap with a confident answer may introduce inaccuracies that become important later.
The same principles apply to favorable facts. Describing yourself as the involved parent is less informative than explaining who attends appointments, communicates with teachers, handles homework, and responds when the child is ill.
Records can clarify the competing accounts
Documents may reveal whether a disputed event happened as described. School attendance records, appointment histories, complete communications, and existing orders can help place individual accounts in context.
Consider an accusation that a parent “never takes the child to the doctor.” Appointment records may show that one parent scheduled most visits while the other attended several. Messages may show that information was not shared consistently. The resulting picture may be more specific than either parent’s first description.
Provide complete, relevant material through the authorized process. Ask counsel before releasing sensitive treatment records, juvenile records, or information subject to a confidentiality restriction. Relevance does not by itself resolve privilege or disclosure questions.
Keep a copy of what you submitted and when. If a report later states that a document was unavailable, that record helps your attorney determine whether there was a misunderstanding, an access problem, or an issue requiring clarification.
Collateral contacts need firsthand information
A collateral contact is someone outside the immediate evaluation interviews who may have relevant information. Depending on the assignment, that may include a teacher, caregiver, healthcare professional, or another person familiar with the child.
Choose proposed contacts for what they know. A teacher may have observed classroom behavior and attendance but may know little about evening exchanges. A relative may have witnessed an exchange while having no independent information about what occurred earlier inside the home.
For each proposed contact, tell counsel the subject, period of involvement, and basis of knowledge. Do not approach the exercise as collecting people willing to say you are a good parent. The value lies in information relevant to the actual dispute.
Observation is another source of information
An evaluator may observe a parent and child interacting when appropriate to the assignment and safety circumstances. Observation can produce information different from a parent’s retrospective description.
Ask what the observation involved and how the report uses it. Was the interaction brief or extended? Structured or unstructured? What happened, what did the evaluator infer, and how does that inference fit with the rest of the information?
A thoughtful review separates the observed behavior from the broader conclusion. If a child was quiet during one meeting, the report should be examined for how that observation was interpreted and what other information supports the interpretation. The setting and limitations matter.
Psychological testing must be connected to a purpose
When testing is included, identify the instrument, its version, and the question it is intended to help answer. Intelligence, achievement, symptoms, personality, parenting stress, and family relationships are different subjects.
For example, a question about a child’s educational support needs may require information different from a question about a parent’s reported symptoms. An inventory does not become a custody test merely because it was administered during a custody case.
Ask whether the professional is qualified to administer and interpret the particular instrument and how the results were considered alongside interviews, records, and observations. If a recommendation relies heavily on a score, your attorney may need qualified assistance to evaluate that connection.
Terms such as “validity scale,” “defensiveness,” or “elevated score” require context. Do not assume that a term in a report establishes a diagnosis, proves a person lied, or decides parenting capacity. Request an explanation from an appropriately qualified professional rather than trying to interpret isolated scores yourself.
Prepare by understanding the instructions and disclosing relevant practical needs. Do not look for preferred answers, rehearse responses, or attempt to influence a testing profile. If you have a concern about language, reading, fatigue, medication, or another testing circumstance, raise it through the proper process.
The reasoning between the information and the conclusion matters
A report may contain accurate facts and still require questions about the inference drawn from them. The useful inquiry is what connects those facts to the specific recommendation.
Suppose a report describes difficult communication and recommends reducing a parent’s school-night time. Counsel should examine why that change addresses the identified problem. Would a defined information-sharing procedure answer it? Is there additional evidence about school performance, transportation, or the child’s needs? What supports the particular restriction?
Under rule 5.220, findings must address relevant information that does not support the conclusions and identify evaluation limitations. That requirement gives counsel a practical reason to ask what alternative explanations were considered and what information remained unavailable.
The existence of another possible explanation does not automatically defeat the opinion. The question is whether the evaluator addressed the important competing information and explained the recommendation adequately.
Safety allegations need focused investigation
Abuse, coercion, and threats should not disappear into a general statement that the parents have poor communication. Identify the alleged conduct, available evidence, and current safety concerns.
Likewise, an allegation should not become an established fact merely because it is repeated. Counsel needs to distinguish the report’s account of what someone said from independent corroboration and the evaluator’s own findings.
Some cases involve specialized statutory requirements. Our section 3118 evaluation guide addresses investigations involving serious child sexual-abuse allegations. Our domestic violence and custody guide explains the separate legal significance of domestic violence.
How Edgar & Dow evaluates the evaluation
Expert evidence is one part of family-law trial work. The trial presentation must connect the requested order to admissible records, reliable testimony, and the applicable legal standard. An expert’s conclusion does not eliminate the need to examine those connections.
At Edgar & Dow, we focus on the assignment, information sources, methods, limitations, and reasoning. That work helps determine what to address on direct examination, what to test on cross-examination, and whether qualified expert consultation is needed. Professional references, including Ackerman and Kane’s Psychological Experts in Divorce Actions, support that inquiry alongside current California authority.
Contact Edgar & Dow to discuss a proposed evaluation or an existing report. Bring the appointment order, report, submission history, and the specific information you believe requires attention.
Common questions
Does every evaluation include psychological tests?
Do not assume that it does. Review the scope and the evaluator’s written description of the procedures. Ask what purpose any proposed testing serves.
Must the evaluator contact every witness I identify?
A list of suggested contacts is not a guarantee that each will be interviewed. Identify what each person knows and why the information matters. Counsel can then assess the significance of a missing source.
Does the recommendation immediately change the order?
The report is not itself a new custody order. Review the existing orders and upcoming hearing requirements with counsel rather than implementing a disputed recommendation on your own.
Professional reference and related reading
Professional reference used by the firm: Marc J. Ackerman and Andrew W. Kane, Psychological Experts in Divorce Actions, 5th ed. (Wolters Kluwer Law & Business, 2011). This is a historical practice reference. The legal authorities and current professional resources linked in this article support the present discussion.
Explore the California Child Custody and Visitation Library for related guidance on parenting time, evidence, evaluations, and contested hearings.
Related