Home
Blog
Custody
A Child’s Statements in a Custody Case: Interviews, Suggestibility, and Hearsay

A Child’s Statements in a Custody Case: Interviews, Suggestibility, and Hearsay

  |    |  
Last Modified on Nov 15, 2026

By H. William Edgar | Edgar & Dow

A child tells a parent something troubling. The parent tells a therapist. A therapist writes a report. An evaluator summarizes that report. By the time the statement reaches court, several adults may have interpreted words they never heard directly.

A careful investigation follows that chain back to its source. What did the child actually say? What question came first? Who was present? Was the conversation recorded? Which details came from the child, and which were supplied later? These questions protect the quality of the evidence and the fairness of the process. They do not assume that the child is mistaken or that the allegation is true.

Start with the original statement and its circumstances

A useful record distinguishes a spontaneous statement from an answer to a question. It identifies the date, setting, people present, words remembered, and action taken. If an adult is reconstructing the conversation from memory, that limitation should remain visible. A later summary should not turn an uncertain recollection into a quotation.

For example, “She said she did not want to go” differs from “She said she was afraid because a particular event happened.” Both deserve attention, but they do not establish the same facts. The adult’s follow-up questions can affect what the conversation means. The child’s exact language matters more than an adult’s conclusion that the child “disclosed abuse.”

Parents should preserve existing messages, recordings, and contemporaneous notes lawfully. They should avoid arranging repeated interviews themselves or asking a child to repeat an account for relatives, a lawyer, or a camera. A child’s need for protection and professional help should take priority over building a collection of statements.

Interview quality is part of the evidence

The federal Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention’s Child Forensic Interviewing: Best Practices discusses developmentally appropriate interviewing, open-ended invitations, and the need to avoid prematurely introducing information. An interviewer must also account for a child’s language, comprehension, and willingness to talk.

Consider the difference between “Tell me what happened at the house” and “He frightened you at the house, didn’t he?” The second question supplies both an event and an interpretation. That does not automatically invalidate every answer that follows. It does create an issue that should be examined in context.

A complete interview recording, when one exists and can lawfully be obtained, is often more informative than selected quotations. Counsel can examine the questions before and after a disputed statement, interruptions, corrections, and whether the interviewer accepted uncertainty. A transcript may preserve the words while missing tone or a long pause. The report should identify what material was actually reviewed.

Suggestibility requires analysis, not a label

Calling a child “suggestible” does not resolve a custody dispute. The useful question is whether an identified influence could explain an identified part of the account. What information was introduced? By whom? Before or after the child’s first statement? Did later descriptions change in a way that corresponds to that information?

Likewise, consistency is not a complete test of truth. A repeated account may be accurate, but repetition alone does not establish its origin. A changing account may reflect many possibilities that require investigation. An expert should explain the reasoning and limitations instead of using consistency, detail, confidence, or emotion as a substitute for corroboration.

More than one interview is not automatically improper. The need for additional inquiry depends on the investigation and the child’s circumstances. The issue is how the interviews were conducted and how their cumulative effect was considered.

A relevant statement may still raise a hearsay problem

California evidence rules require attention to the purpose for which a statement is offered. A statement used to prove that a particular act occurred presents a different question from one offered for another legally relevant purpose. Calling a statement “important” does not establish an exception to the hearsay rule.

Evidence Code section 1240 addresses spontaneous statements concerning an event perceived by the speaker while under the stress of excitement caused by it. Its requirements must be established; a statement does not qualify merely because its subject is upsetting.

Evidence Code section 1250 addresses certain statements of then-existing mental or emotional condition. Its limits matter. A statement of fear and a statement identifying the historical cause of that fear are not interchangeable for every evidentiary purpose.

Another frequently misunderstood provision, Evidence Code section 1360, concerns specified child statements in criminal prosecutions. It is not a general permission to admit every child’s abuse statement in a family-law hearing. The applicable proceeding, foundation, and statutory requirements must be examined.

Putting a statement into a report does not answer every objection

An evaluator’s access to information and the court’s use of that information are separate questions. Counsel should identify the legal basis for admitting the report, the basis for any opinion, and the permissible use of underlying statements. A report can contain several layers of reporting, each requiring attention.

For example, a teacher’s account of what a parent said a child said presents a different foundation from the teacher’s own observation of an injury or classroom behavior. A witness may be highly credible about an observation while lacking personal knowledge of the alleged event.

Preparing the issue for a hearing

At Edgar & Dow, preparation connects the disputed statement to the witness, record, and legal issue needed to evaluate it. That may mean obtaining an original interview, identifying a firsthand witness, consulting a qualified professional, or preparing an objection to an unsupported inference. Cross-examination should expose a meaningful gap without turning the child into the target of the case.

The practical objective is a reliable record and an order that protects the child. For the separate question of how a child may participate in court, see the court’s rule on children’s participation and testimony and our discussion of how courts evaluate children’s statements about abuse.

Professional reference and related reading

Professional reference used by the firm: Marc J. Ackerman and Andrew W. Kane, Psychological Experts in Divorce Actions, 5th ed. (Wolters Kluwer Law & Business, 2011). This is a historical practice reference. The legal authorities and current professional resources linked in this article support the present discussion.

Explore the California Child Custody and Visitation Library for related guidance on parenting time, evidence, evaluations, and contested hearings.

For help preparing your custody case, schedule a consultation with Edgar & Dow.

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

© Copyrights 2026 Edgar & Dow. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

*Images are obtained under license from Canva and other third-party stock image providers, with attribution included where required.

Digital Marketing by rizeup-logo