|
|
Last Modified on Nov 15, 2026
By H. William Edgar | Edgar & Dow
A child may want the judge to understand what daily life is like. That does not mean the child should be brought to court without a plan or asked to choose a winner in the parents’ dispute.
California has procedures for considering a child’s participation, protecting the child, and allowing the parties to address information used in the custody decision. Understanding those procedures is different from asking at what age a child gets to choose where to live.
The child’s views matter, but the child does not decide the case
California Rule of Court 5.250 implements Family Code section 3042. When a child age 14 or older wishes to address the court, the court must hear from the child unless it finds that doing so is not in the child’s best interest and states its reasons. Younger children’s participation is considered according to the applicable standard and circumstances.
These provisions concern participation and consideration of the child’s input. They do not transfer the judge’s decision-making responsibility to the child. Our child-preference guide addresses that separate question.
Tell counsel about the child’s request
Explain what the child said, when, and under what circumstances. Distinguish a spontaneous request to speak from an answer given after repeated questions about which parent the child prefers.
The rule identifies people who must give notice when they learn that a child wishes to address the court or has changed that choice, including appointed professionals. A parent or attorney may also inform the court. Counsel should use the proper procedure rather than arranging an unexpected appearance.
Do not promise that the child will speak privately, that nobody will learn what was said, or that the judge will make the requested order. Those matters depend on the court’s procedures and decisions.
The setting should protect the child
Rule 5.250 generally requires an alternative to the child addressing the court in the parties’ presence, subject to a stated best-interest exception. Protection of the child must be considered alongside the parties’ rights to know and challenge evidence used in the decision.
A child speaking outside the parents’ immediate presence is therefore not the same thing as a secret, unreviewable conversation. Counsel should address who will be present, how the input will be recorded or conveyed, and how questions or objections will be handled.
Raise emotional, developmental, language, disability, and safety concerns early. The method should fit the child and the subject, not simply the adults’ preferences.
What information would help the court?
Focus on the child’s experiences and needs. A child may have useful information about homework routines, transportation, conflict at exchanges, relationships, or events affecting safety. The anticipated subjects should be relevant to the order the court is being asked to make.
A question such as “What happens on school mornings?” seeks information. “Tell the judge why your mother should lose custody” assigns the child an adult legal task and supplies the desired outcome.
Similarly, an older child’s preference may need context. The court may need to understand its reasons, the practical consequences, and whether the proposed arrangement meets the child’s needs. The child’s statement is part of that inquiry.
There may be alternatives to courtroom testimony
Depending on the case and the court’s decisions, information may be obtained through an evaluator, recommending counselor, appointed counsel for the child, or another authorized process. These roles have different functions and limits.
Do not treat an interview with a therapist as interchangeable with sworn testimony. Nor should a child’s attorney be described simply as a witness who repeats everything the child has said. Our minor’s counsel guide explains that role.
Counsel should identify what information is needed and whether the proposed method allows it to be obtained fairly and safely. Convenience alone should not decide how the child’s voice is presented.
Preparation should explain the process, not supply the answers
A child may need a simple explanation of the setting, who the people are, and that it is acceptable to ask for clarification or say they do not remember. The appropriate professional and counsel should consider how that explanation is given.
Do not rehearse allegations, reward a particular account, or repeatedly test whether the child will give the answer you want. Do not show the child adult declarations and ask for agreement with their wording.
If the child is frightened, identify the actual concern. Fear of seeing a parent, uncertainty about the courtroom, and worry about disappointing an adult may require different arrangements. Avoid interpreting the concern as proof of the underlying dispute before it is investigated.
Participation and admissibility are separate issues
A child may have important information, but the court still needs an appropriate evidentiary process. Questions of personal knowledge, the child’s ability to understand and communicate, the manner of examination, and hearsay may arise.
A parent’s declaration saying “my child told me” is not automatically equivalent to the child testifying. Likewise, an evaluator’s report does not eliminate every question about the statements within it. Counsel must identify the particular route by which information is offered.
This is why trial preparation begins before the hearing. The child’s protection and the fairness of the evidentiary process both require planning.
If the child changes their mind
A child may initially want to speak and later hesitate, or may become willing after learning more about the process. Notify counsel rather than pressuring the child to keep a commitment made earlier.
Rule 5.250 expressly addresses changes in the child’s choice. The court and involved professionals need accurate information to make appropriate arrangements. A change should be examined in context, not automatically treated as proof that someone manipulated the child.
How Edgar & Dow prepares for a child’s participation
At Edgar & Dow, we consider the disputed issues, the child’s needs, the proposed evidence, and the available procedure. Preparation includes the method of participation, witness and exhibit issues, and the opportunity to address information relied on by the court.
The aim is to help the judge receive useful information while keeping the child out of responsibility for the adult litigation. Contact Edgar & Dow before bringing a child to a hearing or arranging a statement for the court.
Common questions
Must my child testify because the other parent wants it?
No automatic rule follows from a parent’s request alone. The court must apply the governing standards and consider the circumstances.
Can I promise the child that the conversation is confidential?
No. Ask counsel about the actual process. The court must consider both protection of the child and the parties’ rights concerning evidence.
Professional reference and related reading
Professional reference used by the firm: Marc J. Ackerman and Andrew W. Kane, Psychological Experts in Divorce Actions, 5th ed. (Wolters Kluwer Law & Business, 2011). This is a historical practice reference. The legal authorities and current professional resources linked in this article support the present discussion.
Explore the California Child Custody and Visitation Library for related guidance on parenting time, evidence, evaluations, and contested hearings.
Related