|
|
Last Modified on Nov 15, 2026
By H. William Edgar | Edgar & Dow
The right expert is someone qualified to answer the question your case actually presents. An impressive résumé is useful background, but it does not establish that every opinion the person offers is reliable, relevant, or admissible.
In family-law litigation, psychological expertise may become relevant to custody, alleged abuse, disputed mental health issues, or the interpretation of an evaluation. Before selecting an expert, identify the legal issue, the facts in dispute, and the specialized knowledge the court may need.
Define the assignment before choosing the person
Do you need a court-appointed custody evaluation, confidential consultation about another expert’s methods, or an expert who may testify? Those assignments may involve different procedures, access to information, and costs.
A request to “help us win custody” does not define a professional assignment. A useful question is more specific: Does the report’s testing support the stated conclusion? Did the evaluation investigate the reasons for the child’s refusal to visit? What information would be needed to assess an alleged impairment in parenting?
The assignment should also identify what the expert is not being asked to do. A professional reviewing a report may be able to discuss its methods without having a sufficient basis to recommend a complete parenting plan. That limit should be addressed at the beginning.
California separates general expert qualification from custody-evaluator requirements
Evidence Code section 720 concerns whether a witness has sufficient specialized knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education on the subject of the proposed testimony. The fit between the expertise and the opinion is central.
A court-appointed child custody evaluator must also satisfy the applicable appointment requirements. Rule 5.225 addresses licensing, training, experience, and continuing education, with specified exceptions. Domestic violence training is separately addressed in rule 5.230.
These requirements should not be collapsed into one question. A retained expert reviewing a narrow methodological issue is not automatically serving as the court-appointed custody evaluator. Counsel must examine the person’s actual role and the requirements that apply to it.
Look for experience with the problem, not just the general field
A professional may have extensive clinical experience and limited experience explaining forensic conclusions in court. Another may have testified often but lack specialized experience with the particular child’s needs or the assessment method in dispute.
Ask what the expert has actually done. Relevant subjects may include developmental differences, psychological testing, domestic violence, substance-use assessment, trauma, or the investigation of allegations involving children. The case should drive the inquiry.
For example, a dispute involving a child’s educational supports may require familiarity with the records and assessments underlying those services. A dispute involving an adult personality inventory calls for expertise with the instrument and the inferences being drawn from it. The same professional may or may not be suited to both.
Ask when the relevant work was performed and what training keeps the professional current. A source or credential from years earlier is a starting point for questions, not a complete answer about present expertise.
Review the qualifications and any required disclosures
Obtain the current résumé, verify licensure through the appropriate board, and identify the relevant professional training and experience. Consider any disclosed limitations, conflicts, or disciplinary information in context rather than relying on an informal reputation.
For a private court-appointed custody evaluator, the qualifications declaration is important. Riverside Superior Court’s information for litigants directs attention to the Declaration of Private Child Custody Evaluator Regarding Qualifications, form FL-326, and the applicable training standards.
Ask whether the professional has previously treated a family member, consulted in the matter, or had another connection that could affect the assignment. A potential conflict should be disclosed and evaluated before the work proceeds.
Examine the proposed method
An expert should be able to explain the information needed to answer the question. Will there be interviews, record review, observations, testing, consultation, or some combination? What are the practical limits if a record or participant is unavailable?
Consider an opinion that a parent’s behavior caused a child’s rejection of the other parent. Counsel should examine how the professional proposes to investigate alternative explanations, such as the child’s own experiences, safety concerns, conflict between adults, or problems in the parent-child relationship.
That does not minimize the seriousness of deliberate interference. It identifies what a persuasive investigation must address. A conclusion becomes more useful when the expert can explain the evidence supporting it and the information that might point in another direction.
Similarly, if the opinion will rely on testing, ask why that instrument is appropriate for the question and how its results will be interpreted. A familiar test name does not substitute for a supported application.
Look for impartial reasoning
The following questions help examine potential bias. They are questions for evaluating the work, not diagnoses of the professional:
- Did the expert settle on an explanation before considering the important contrary information?
- Were similar statements from the two parents evaluated using different standards?
- Did the expert assume that gender, income, diagnosis, or social background established parenting ability?
- Did the evaluator’s prior treatment or other relationship affect the assignment?
- Can the expert identify what information would change or limit the opinion?
An unfavorable conclusion does not establish bias. The stronger inquiry identifies the particular statement, decision, or omission and explains why it matters.
For instance, if one parent’s account was accepted without corroboration while a comparable account from the other parent was rejected for lacking corroboration, counsel can ask what justified the different treatment. There may be a reasonable explanation. The report and testimony should allow that explanation to be examined.
Qualification does not settle the admissibility of every opinion
A person can be qualified in a field while offering an opinion that exceeds the available information. The basis and reasoning require separate attention.
In Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California (2012) 55 Cal.4th 747, the California Supreme Court explained the court’s role in examining unsupported or speculative expert reasoning under Evidence Code sections 801 and 802. Although Sargon was not a custody case, it is important California authority on the admissibility of expert opinions.
A methodological disagreement does not automatically require exclusion. Counsel must distinguish an objection to admissibility from an argument about the weight the judge should give the evidence. Both may be important, but they call for different legal analysis and preparation.
Consider whether the expert can explain the work
The expert’s reasoning must be understandable to the court. Ask how the person explains technical terms, acknowledges limitations, and distinguishes observation from inference.
Preparation for direct examination should identify the assignment, qualifications, methods, factual basis, and opinions the witness can properly give. Preparation for cross-examination should examine the weak points as carefully as the favorable ones.
An expert who cannot explain why a particular fact matters may not solve the case’s evidentiary problem. Conversely, a clear explanation of a narrow issue may be valuable even if it does not answer every question in the litigation.
Discuss fees, access, and timing early
Request a clear description of the proposed services, billing structure, anticipated records, and likely additional charges for reports, conferences, deposition, or trial. Ask what can reasonably be completed before the relevant deadlines.
A full re-evaluation may be unnecessary where the dispute concerns one interpretation or a readily corrected factual assumption. A targeted consultation may be insufficient where the needed opinion requires interviews and new data. The scope should match the task.
Access to records can also control what is possible. Do not assume that hiring a reviewer permits unrestricted sharing of confidential custody reports or protected testing material. Counsel should address the applicable permissions and procedures.
Why this is part of family-law trial preparation
Family-law trials require attention to the entire evidentiary presentation: burdens of proof, documents, witnesses, foundations, objections, direct examination, and cross-examination. Psychological expertise is one component of that work.
At Edgar & Dow, we assess the expert’s contribution in relation to the issue the judge must decide. We use professional resources, including Ackerman and Kane’s Psychological Experts in Divorce Actions, while evaluating the current law and the particular evidence. The objective is a clear, supported presentation of the case.
Contact Edgar & Dow to discuss a proposed expert or an evaluation already underway. Bring the existing orders, the professional’s proposed assignment, any report, and the relevant hearing dates.
Common questions
Can the parties agree on an evaluator?
An agreement may be part of the appointment process, but the proposed role, applicable qualifications, and court approval still need attention. Do not assume that agreement eliminates every qualification or conflict issue.
Should I hire someone who promises a favorable opinion?
The opinion should follow an appropriate examination of the information. A proposed expert should be willing to identify limitations and facts that do not support your position.
Does an experienced therapist automatically qualify as a forensic expert?
No. Examine the relevant qualifications, proposed subject, and assignment. Treatment experience may be valuable, but the particular forensic opinion still needs an adequate foundation.
Professional reference and related reading
Professional reference used by the firm: Marc J. Ackerman and Andrew W. Kane, Psychological Experts in Divorce Actions, 5th ed. (Wolters Kluwer Law & Business, 2011). This is a historical practice reference. The legal authorities and current professional resources linked in this article support the present discussion.
Explore the California Child Custody and Visitation Library for related guidance on parenting time, evidence, evaluations, and contested hearings.
Related